Island Coffee Shop is a beloved culinary gem nestled in Staten Island, at 407 Manor Rd, New York, NY. This unclaimed diner ticks all the boxes for those seeking hearty New American and classic American fare. What's remarkable about this spot is its ability to deliver comfort food that feels both familiar and satisfying. And let’s not forget their rich coffee, a staple for many loyal patrons.

Upon entering Island Coffee Shop, you’re met with a warm, inviting atmosphere reminiscent of traditional diners. The constant buzz suggests a thriving environment where friends and families gather—it’s not uncommon to find a line of eager customers waiting patiently by the door. Regulars adore the routine: they line up, place their orders (don’t forget your number!), and settle in for a meal that feels less like dining out and more like gathering around a family table. As noted by reviewer Ree C., the wait is always worth it, with delicious meals that boast generous portions at unbeatable prices.

Among the favorites are the turkey-bacon BLT on rye, which many consider a personal best. The menu also features an array of delightful wraps, including the Turkey Wrap and Shrimp Avocado Wrap—a perfect mix for anyone craving something lighter. For a true taste of comfort, the Chef's recommendation of Chicken Marsala showcases the depth of flavor that can be found in this seemingly simple diner. Each dish, from the creamy Swiss cheese to the hearty Reuben wraps, reflects the quality and dedication of the staff, many of whom have been part of the shop's texture for years.

Island Coffee Shop isn’t just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community institution. The friendly service keeps patrons coming back, and the environment fosters a sense of belonging. Christopher D. and Rashid B. echo this sentiment, highlighting the attentiveness of the staff and the fast local delivery service. Whether you're in for breakfast or lunch, the comfort food—ranging from classic eggs and bacon to hearty sandwiches—never disappoints. The coffee, always refillable, keeps the conversation flowing, ensuring that every visit is memorable.

In short, whether you're a long-time Staten Island local or just passing through, Island Coffee Shop promises a dining experience filled with warmth, taste, and community spirit. Bring your cash and an appetite for a delightful array of flavors that embody the essence of American comfort food. This café is more than just a spot to eat; it’s a cherished part of the neighborhood fabric, one delicious meal at a time.